1) When Gutterson says “Green Valley is as much a verb as a noun,” he is referring to the community Green Valley as being an active place. He describes various activities such as “homes going up, developments going in…” (183) Next, he goes more in depth about the city laws and what they prohibit and require. For example, Gutterson explains, “Walls are everywhere in Green Valley too; they’re the first thing a visitor notices…. the gates at the thresholds… their guards… (186) ten o’ clock teen curfew… ‘lot owners shall not change said walls in any manner’; ‘perimeter walls are required around all single family residential projects’… ‘Perimeter Project Walls… shall be made gray colored, split face concrete masonry units, 8” by 16” by 6” in size, with a 4” high gray split face, concrete block....” “All of Green Valley is defined in this manner, by CC&Rs, as the planners call them---covenants, conditions, and restrictions embedded in deeds….” (187)
2) Gutterson’s tone is condemning and sarcastic in an overall subtle way. He achieves this tone using facts and examples. For instance, he opens by presenting Green Valley as a desirable place to live and then crushes this idea with facts pertaining to restrictions and requirements that are rather tedious and unappealing. However, his sarcastic and condemning tone is persuasive because he doesn’t destroy his ethos by using and outright bashing tone.
3) I agree that suburbs are not the safe, selective paradises they purport to be. While I do not have particular experience with suburbs, life experience proves that people of all different places have problems. As Gutterson says, “Last year a rapist ran loose in its neighborhoods;… referring to the gangs… teenagers who told me that LSD and crystal meth are the narcotics of choice at Green Valley High School, to the doctor who simply rolled his eyes when I asked if he thought AIDS have arrived here.… the protection they provide is an illusion….” (188) People are people; we’re none exactly the same. While striving to be a better person, a better community is important, this is not achieved robotically.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment